Global shareholdings, taxes, royalties and fees - harvesting a share for us all
Although pilot schemes for world basic income may be funded through international aid or charitable giving, we envisage that in the long term a whole-world basic income would be funded through new global mechanisms, which would aim to harvest a share of the of the wealth that our ancestors have built up over the centuries, and that the earth yields now. This could be gathered through collective shareholdings in global companies, international taxes, such as a carbon tax or financial transaction tax, royalties on goods like intellectual property or the extraction of natural resources, or fees for the use of shared goods, such as charging airlines a fee for using our shared airspace.
These are relatively new ideas, and here at World Basic Income we are under no illusions as to how difficult they may be to put it in place. Nevertheless, the G77 is already calling for a UN Tax Body to tackle elite tax abuse and the 'race to the bottom' in corporate taxation, and there is pressure from many sides for global financial transparency. Once these crucial aims are achieved, it makes sense to consider how else a global tax body could further global social justice and sustainability - global taxes and other charges could become an obvious next step. We at World Basic Income believe that it is right to gather up wealth at this global level, and that this could bring huge benefits if shared out as a world basic income. We will work to research the options, initiate discussions and push forward progress, to find sustainable ways to fund it.
The table below summarises some funding options for World Basic Income, and more discussion of these is given further down the page.
These are relatively new ideas, and here at World Basic Income we are under no illusions as to how difficult they may be to put it in place. Nevertheless, the G77 is already calling for a UN Tax Body to tackle elite tax abuse and the 'race to the bottom' in corporate taxation, and there is pressure from many sides for global financial transparency. Once these crucial aims are achieved, it makes sense to consider how else a global tax body could further global social justice and sustainability - global taxes and other charges could become an obvious next step. We at World Basic Income believe that it is right to gather up wealth at this global level, and that this could bring huge benefits if shared out as a world basic income. We will work to research the options, initiate discussions and push forward progress, to find sustainable ways to fund it.
The table below summarises some funding options for World Basic Income, and more discussion of these is given further down the page.
There is more than enough
Immense amounts of wealth flow around the world every day. The world's Gross National Income - the total wealth we produce each year - is around $76 trillion. We need to re-direct only a tiny part of it - around 1.2% - to fund a world basic income.
In doing so we take nothing away - we simply divert a small part of this income flow directly into people's pockets. Once people spend their basic income, this money is of course returned back into the global wealth stream to be earned, sold, and to flow round once again.
In doing so we take nothing away - we simply divert a small part of this income flow directly into people's pockets. Once people spend their basic income, this money is of course returned back into the global wealth stream to be earned, sold, and to flow round once again.
A whole world of resources
There are lots of world resources that we could considered to be shared, either because their value is created through our collective efforts, or because they exist naturally without human effort. We could divert a small share of the income produced by these collective and natural resources to fund a world basic income, so that everyone in the world benefits from this collective wealth.
|
A collective share in global corporations. Thinkers such as Yanis Varoufakis have proposed funding basic income by requiring that a percentage of the shares sold via Initial Public Offerings be held by a Commons Capital Depository. A proportion of the dividends paid out to shareholders by companies would then accumulate in a collective fund which would be distributed to everyone worldwide as a basic income. This idea recognises that corporations make money partly through the use of ideas, people, infrastructure and natural resources that have been publicly funded or are collectively owned, so the public deserve a share in the proceeds.
|
|
Our money, and the real value within financial products. High finance only works if traders have 'confidence' in the products being exchanged. To create confidence, products have to originate in the real economy of useful things. Currencies and bonds get their value from the fact that populations go out to work and pay their taxes. Derivatives are based on farmers actually growing food next year, and on real earning people taking out mortgages on real homes. Without our hard work, the immense wealth within the finance sector would disappear, so it seems fair to ask that a portion of this wealth is shared among the people of the world that helped to create it.
|
|
Our atmosphere and the right to pollute it. Many proponents of basic income propose a 'carbon tax', which recognises that, just as waste authorities have to pay for landfill sites to dump solid rubbish, it is reasonable to also charge for the right to dump CO2 in the atmosphere. This tax would overwhelmingly fall on well-off people and corporations, as they use most of the world's fossil fuels.
|
|
Our oceans and airspace, and the right to travel through them. Transnational shipping of goods, and aviation, are huge industries which rely on the use of these immense shared resources. We as the world's people could choose to charge for passage or freight through our airspace and oceans, and share this money out amongst us all.
|
|
Our land. Most of us either have no access to land or we spend our lives renting or paying off the huge cost of a tiny parcel of it. In line with longstanding campaigns for Land Value Tax, owners of large areas of land could be required to contribute a proportion of the revenue they generate with it (in rents, agricultural produce or capital gains) to the world's people, in recognition that we all have a shared moral claim on the land.
|
|
The riches beneath the land. Gold, diamonds, oil, iron and other minerals all occur naturally yet they are traded for vastly more than what it costs to extract them. Although it may be unjust to begin extracting global dividends from these resources now, when the world's best off countries got rich centuries ago from selling theirs freely, these are nevertheless resources that can be considered to be common property at least by the people who live in areas where they still exist. There may be socially just ways to accrue a fair dividend from their extraction.
|
|
Energy from the wind, sun, rivers and waves. As energy prices rise, landowners who happen to possess windy hills, or who can stake a claim to sunny deserts or fast-flowing rivers, may make a fortune by selling us the output of our own weather. Although these are benign energy sources and their development should be encouraged, in time (especially as revenues from carbon taxes diminish) it may become right to gather a share of their revenues for humanity. |
Riches from space. Near-earth asteroids contain valuable minerals, and some companies are already lining up to mine them. As no one privately owns asteroids, it seems reasonable to consider them to be in shared ownership. Therefore some or all of the gains from asteroids should surely be shared among the people of earth, just as the people of a country (or their government) usually expect a share of the proceeds from mining beneath their lands. Other riches from space, including space itself and the right to keep satellites there, could be treated the same way.
Intellectual property, and the making of money from it. The fortunes made by Bill Gates and others programmers, writers and inventors were only possible because many people had built up knowledge before them, often for little or no pay. Our ancestors created this immensely valuable store of knowledge together, and we all deserve to share in the bounty created from it.
Intellectual property, and the making of money from it. The fortunes made by Bill Gates and others programmers, writers and inventors were only possible because many people had built up knowledge before them, often for little or no pay. Our ancestors created this immensely valuable store of knowledge together, and we all deserve to share in the bounty created from it.
How much could we raise for a world basic income?
As described above, there are many more sources from which we could derive all or part of a world basic income. We can choose to tap into these stores and flows of wealth as much as the people of the world consider to be appropriate. But it helps to have numbers, and we at World Basic Income will work hard to provide them. If you or your organisation would be interested in helping us develop better estimates for the amounts that could be raised from any of these sources or others, please do get in touch with us.
Based on current research, the following proposed taxes give an idea of some options for funding the $900 billion per year that we need to fund a $10 a month basic income for all of us.
Carbon tax - Based on current levels of carbon dioxide output (circa 35 gigatonnes per year), and a suggestion by the IMF of a '$59 per tonne of CO2' carbon tax, over $165 billion could be raised every month, which is more than double the amount we would need.
A collective share in corporations - The BBC reported in 2015 that global dividend pay-outs had reached $1.167 trillion in the last year. If 10% of those dividends were diverted into a Commons Capital Depository, this would raise $116.7 billion, enough for about one and a half month's world basic income each year. If the people's share in corporations was raised to 20%, this could cover three months of basic income, and if 40%, half of each year's world basic income could be funded in this way.
Financial transaction tax - Estimates vary as to how much could be raised: The Institute for Development Studies found that $26 billion could be raised a year just by taxing foreign exchange transactions, while taxing other financial products as well 'could raise much larger sums'. A United Nations working group concluded that around $80 billion could be raised each year with very tiny transaction taxes. A report to the IMF by a coalition of organisations concluded that $150 billion could be raised a year immediately, rising to $376 billion once stamp duty on share trading is included. These amounts are variable - however, it looks like between one and five months of the year's world basic income could be funded by a financial transaction tax according to current proposals.
Taxing wealthy people - The economist Thomas Piketty has proposed a very low rate wealth tax on those with net assets above $1 million, and a higher rate for even richer people, which could bring in 'a few hundred billion dollars a year'. Such a tax could therefore fund a few months' of world basic income.
Royalties on intellectual property - Peter Barnes, author of With Liberty and Dividends For All calculates the money that could be raised just within the USA, if a 20% tax (similar to the UK's Value Added Tax) were applied to the sale of patented or copyrighted goods within the 15 most patent- and copyright-intensive industries. He finds that $320 billion could be raised each year in this way. If we assume that the whole world's sales of intellectual property goods is five times that of the USA, and reduce the tax to just 2%, this would raise $160 billion per year, which is enough to pay for more than two months of world basic income.
Land value tax - Data on global land values is not easily available, so World Basic Income has made some very rough and conservative estimates. Martin Farley, author of The Tranformation Deal proposes a land value tax for the U.S. and in doing so provides some data on land values there. From this estimate ($43.3bn worth of land value in the U.S.), we make a guess that there might be on average $5 trillion worth of land in each of the 35 OECD countries, plus $1 trillion on average in each of the 160 other countries, counting only land holdings that are worth more than $5,000 (only the value of the land itself counts, not the value of any buildings or infrastructure built on it). We then suggest a global land value tax rate of 0.5%, which is ten times lower than that proposed by Martin Farley. This gives an annual global revenue of $3.35 trillion. However, clearly the method for reaching these figures is especially rough, so this figure is intended to provide a sense of scale only. The actual amounts raised could be much smaller or much larger, depending on actual global land values, the threshold at which we choose to begin charging the tax, and the chosen tax rate.
All of the amounts provided above are only illustrative, and much more work needs to be done to understand the effects of raising money in these ways, and the true potential of these revenue streams.
However, what remains clear is that there is no shortage of money. The figures provided here already suggest that a basic income far beyond $10 per person per month could be provided, if all revenue streams were tapped effectively. And we need not be limited by the options proposed above. Trillions of dollars change hands every day on world financial markets, and the world's billionaires alone have assets worth over $6 trillion. Ultimately, the amount that can be raised for a world basic income depends on public opinion and political will.
Based on current research, the following proposed taxes give an idea of some options for funding the $900 billion per year that we need to fund a $10 a month basic income for all of us.
Carbon tax - Based on current levels of carbon dioxide output (circa 35 gigatonnes per year), and a suggestion by the IMF of a '$59 per tonne of CO2' carbon tax, over $165 billion could be raised every month, which is more than double the amount we would need.
A collective share in corporations - The BBC reported in 2015 that global dividend pay-outs had reached $1.167 trillion in the last year. If 10% of those dividends were diverted into a Commons Capital Depository, this would raise $116.7 billion, enough for about one and a half month's world basic income each year. If the people's share in corporations was raised to 20%, this could cover three months of basic income, and if 40%, half of each year's world basic income could be funded in this way.
Financial transaction tax - Estimates vary as to how much could be raised: The Institute for Development Studies found that $26 billion could be raised a year just by taxing foreign exchange transactions, while taxing other financial products as well 'could raise much larger sums'. A United Nations working group concluded that around $80 billion could be raised each year with very tiny transaction taxes. A report to the IMF by a coalition of organisations concluded that $150 billion could be raised a year immediately, rising to $376 billion once stamp duty on share trading is included. These amounts are variable - however, it looks like between one and five months of the year's world basic income could be funded by a financial transaction tax according to current proposals.
Taxing wealthy people - The economist Thomas Piketty has proposed a very low rate wealth tax on those with net assets above $1 million, and a higher rate for even richer people, which could bring in 'a few hundred billion dollars a year'. Such a tax could therefore fund a few months' of world basic income.
Royalties on intellectual property - Peter Barnes, author of With Liberty and Dividends For All calculates the money that could be raised just within the USA, if a 20% tax (similar to the UK's Value Added Tax) were applied to the sale of patented or copyrighted goods within the 15 most patent- and copyright-intensive industries. He finds that $320 billion could be raised each year in this way. If we assume that the whole world's sales of intellectual property goods is five times that of the USA, and reduce the tax to just 2%, this would raise $160 billion per year, which is enough to pay for more than two months of world basic income.
Land value tax - Data on global land values is not easily available, so World Basic Income has made some very rough and conservative estimates. Martin Farley, author of The Tranformation Deal proposes a land value tax for the U.S. and in doing so provides some data on land values there. From this estimate ($43.3bn worth of land value in the U.S.), we make a guess that there might be on average $5 trillion worth of land in each of the 35 OECD countries, plus $1 trillion on average in each of the 160 other countries, counting only land holdings that are worth more than $5,000 (only the value of the land itself counts, not the value of any buildings or infrastructure built on it). We then suggest a global land value tax rate of 0.5%, which is ten times lower than that proposed by Martin Farley. This gives an annual global revenue of $3.35 trillion. However, clearly the method for reaching these figures is especially rough, so this figure is intended to provide a sense of scale only. The actual amounts raised could be much smaller or much larger, depending on actual global land values, the threshold at which we choose to begin charging the tax, and the chosen tax rate.
All of the amounts provided above are only illustrative, and much more work needs to be done to understand the effects of raising money in these ways, and the true potential of these revenue streams.
However, what remains clear is that there is no shortage of money. The figures provided here already suggest that a basic income far beyond $10 per person per month could be provided, if all revenue streams were tapped effectively. And we need not be limited by the options proposed above. Trillions of dollars change hands every day on world financial markets, and the world's billionaires alone have assets worth over $6 trillion. Ultimately, the amount that can be raised for a world basic income depends on public opinion and political will.
How did they become rich anyway?
Some of the funding mechanisms that we support at World Basic Income would impact disproportionately on rich people. This is no accident - here at World Basic Income, we believe inequality is a problem both because it is unjust and because it causes hardship and social problems, so we want to reduce it through progressive redistribution. We believe that you don't become a millionaire just by working hard - most people work hard, and yet never become rich. You need the workers in the companies you own (or invest in) to work hard too. You need producers of raw materials to work hard, so they can sell them to you at a price that turns you a profit. You need the world's farmers to work hard, so that you and your workforce can exist at all. You even need the world's unemployed people to keep on scraping by, to help keep your workers' wage demands in check.
At World Basic Income, we believe that rich people and businesses only managed to get rich because millions of us helped them along the way. Although the world economy tends to direct money up the economic pyramid, it doesn't mean it belongs there, or should stay there. It seems perfectly reasonable that a small, regular share be taken from these accumulations of wealth to give back to the people of the world.
At World Basic Income, we believe that rich people and businesses only managed to get rich because millions of us helped them along the way. Although the world economy tends to direct money up the economic pyramid, it doesn't mean it belongs there, or should stay there. It seems perfectly reasonable that a small, regular share be taken from these accumulations of wealth to give back to the people of the world.










